Detailed descriptions of each of the scenarios modeled.


 
Scenario Name Description
IMPERV changes in % impervious and % commercial area over entire basin. Changes were a 5, 10, and 50% increase, and 5% decrease in the % impervious and % commercial. % commercial changes were limited by amount of "natural" area, with natural areas reduced by same amount that commercial was increased. 
CHAN_ROUGH Increase Manning's N for the channels by 0.0185, which is the difference between Clean, Straight Banks channel and a Stony, Winding Pools and Shoals channel 
CHANNELIZ Channelization of Miller Cr Mainstem down to middle DNR data site. Two methods: short fractal (500 ft) and long fractal (1500 ft) used to compute new lengths. Slope werechanged by back-calculating the "rise" from the original length and slope, and using the new length to re-calculate a new slope.
TRIBSEW Upper Basin tribs were converted into stormsewers by: changing channel to pipe, reducing roughness, and decreasing length/increasing slope. NO changes in Miller Mainstem. 
DET_POND Detention ponds were added to each modeled Miller Creek Trib from headwaters to the middle DNR data site. Ponds were exact same size, with same outlet, as for the Miller Hill Mall basin. Ponds were put in place just before trib entered Miller Creek, and downstream (and in addition to) any existing features such as natural ponds, culverts, etc. Stormsewered sections had detention ponds added as well. Where multiple tribs combined before entering Miller Creek, each trib had a pond added PRIOR to the joining of the tribs 
ROUGH_IMPERV Increased roughness and surface storage by ratio of 1.1 (10%) for all subcatchments in Model. no other changes performed. Scenario proposed as possible BMP, to increase retention time and depression storage of rainfall on impervious areas.
COMBO Two combinations: 1st, without BMP's, includes 10% increase in imperv and commercial areas, channelized Miller Cr (500 ft fractal), and tributaries in upper basin converted to stormsewers (as in tribstosewer model). 2nd combo includes previous changes along with BMP's: detention ponds at end of all tribs, increased mainstem channel roughness, increased impervious roughness and surface storage (see rough_Imperv scenario), and trib stormsewers roughness increased to 0.0255 (corresponding to the max n for metal corrugated pipe). 
RESIDENT altered buildup rate of Tot-P in residential landuses; increases and decreases of 10% in buildup rate for both hi-density and low-density residential landuses. Only Tot-P data altered.
4 December, 1999 Jesse Schomberg

 

The Lake Superior Decision Support project is coordinated through the Center for Water and the Environment at the Natural Resources Research Institute. The project is funded by the USEPA Region 5 Coastal Environmental Management Grant Program through the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.  For comments on this project or this home page, contact George Host.  Last updated: Friday, January 18, 2002 11:44
The University of Minnesota is an equal opportunity educator and employer.
© 1999-2000 University of Minnesota Duluth
Natural Resources Research Institute
CWE
5013 Miller Trunk Highway
Duluth, MN 55811 (218)720.4294